Guide

How long to keep old insurance policies

No official source sets one period for old insurance policies. Keep the current policy and its declarations page while it is in force, and keep an expired policy until every claim from its coverage period is settled. Many people keep old liability policies longer, since a claim about an accident in that period can come later. Keep health coverage records with that year’s tax file, as the IRS asks, and keep life insurance policies until they pay out, somewhere your family can find them.

Last checked

This page is general information, not insurance, tax or legal advice. No official source sets one keeping period for insurance policies, so parts of this page are reasoning, and they say so. Your insurer, agent or a lawyer can tell you what applies to you.

There is no single official rule

For tax records, the IRS gives clear periods. For bank statements and pay stubs, the FTC suggests a year. For insurance policies, neither gives a number. The FTC’s keep-or-shred list doesn’t name insurance policies at all, and the only insurance item on it is “offers of credit or insurance”, in the shred pile.

The IRS’s general advice does apply, though: before you throw records away, check whether someone else, such as an insurer, needs you to keep them longer.

So instead of a rule, here is the reasoning people use. It comes down to one question: could a claim about this policy period still come up?

The reasoning, policy by policy

Policy What people usually keep The reasoning Official source
Any current policy The full policy, the declarations page and every endorsement, while it is in force It is your contract and what you would need for a claim NAIC, CA DOI
Home and renters, expired Until every claim from that period is closed; some keep the last few years Damage found late, or a liability claim from that period None: reasoning
Auto, expired Until every claim from that period is closed; many keep a few years longer Someone may claim about an accident months later None: reasoning
Umbrella and other liability Longer than the others; many keep them for years Liability claims can arrive long after the event None: reasoning
Health insurance With that year’s tax records The IRS asks for records of health coverage IRS
Life insurance and annuities Until they pay out They are worth money to your family NAIC
Claim files Until the claim is settled, plus any appeal Proof of what was paid and agreed None: reasoning
Insurance offers, and cards once replaced Shred Nothing left to prove FTC, for offers

The “reasoning” rows are exactly that. If an old policy really matters, for example after a serious accident or a lawsuit threat, ask your insurer or a lawyer rather than relying on a general rule.

Home and auto: keep the declarations pages

The declarations page is the one or two pages at the front of a policy that say who and what is covered, the coverages, the limits, the deductibles and the premium. The NAIC notes that if your declarations page is wrong, it could cause problems if you file a claim.

Each renewal brings a new one. Keeping last year’s next to this year’s is the simplest way to see what changed, and the California Department of Insurance says there is no substitute for reading your policy and your renewal declarations carefully. The guide to spotting changes at renewal shows how to compare them, and what to check before you renew covers the rest.

Keep your home inventory with the policy too. The California guide advises keeping a list of what you own with the dates you bought each item and the price, and updating it, along with photos or video. You will want it most on the day you can’t get into the house, so keep a copy outside it.

Health insurance: it is a tax record

Topic 305 tells you to keep records of your own and your family’s health coverage, and if you claim the premium tax credit, the information on advance payments and premiums paid. Those papers belong in that year’s tax folder and follow the tax clock: usually 3 years after you file. See how long to keep tax records.

Life insurance: keep it where your family can find it

A life insurance policy is worth nothing if no one knows it exists. Keep the policy, or at least a page with the insurer, the policy number and the beneficiaries, with your will or in your emergency document binder, and tell someone where it is.

If a policy goes missing after a death, the NAIC runs a free Life Insurance Policy Locator. A family member submits the details from the death certificate, participating insurers search their records, and if a policy is found and the person asking is the beneficiary, the insurer contacts them.

Where Scanner One helps, and where it doesn’t

Scanner One does not know what your policy covers or whether a claim is still possible. That is between you and your insurer.

It does keep every policy and declarations page in one place, readable and searchable. Point your camera at any piece of paper. Scanner One finds the edges, straightens the page, cleans it up and saves a real PDF. A scan can have many pages, and you can reorder them. Then it reads the text, names the document, tags it and puts it in the right folder. Search looks inside the text of every document and shows the matching line and page.

Ask your documents anything. When does the lease end? What did I spend at the shop? The answer comes back with the page it came from. You can ask for a deductible or a renewal date and see the page the answer came from. On a free account you can ask 3 questions a day.

What changed compares the new version of a lease or policy with the one you signed.

Documents stay on your iPhone unless you share them or turn on iCloud Sync. You can lock the app with Face ID. If you share a policy from a free account, On a free account, pages you share, print or export carry a small “Scanned with Scanner One” label at the bottom right. Pro removes it.

If your insurer’s app keeps every policy year and you can always download them, that may be enough on its own.

Questions and answers

Should I keep old car insurance policies?

Keep each one until any claim from its coverage period is closed. Many people keep old auto policies a few years longer, in case someone makes a claim about an accident from that period. No official source sets the length, so this is reasoning, not a rule; ask your insurer or agent if you are unsure.

Do I need to keep insurance cards after they expire?

No. Once the new card arrives and the old policy period has no open claims, the old card can be shredded. It carries your policy number and name, so shred it rather than throwing it away.

How long should I keep health insurance records for taxes?

Keep them with that year’s tax records, for as long as the IRS can question the return, usually 3 years. Topic 305 asks you to keep records of your own and your family’s health coverage, and of premiums and advance payments if you claim the premium tax credit.

How can my family find my life insurance policy?

Tell them where you keep it, and keep a copy with your will or emergency papers. If a policy is lost after a death, the NAIC’s free Life Insurance Policy Locator lets a family member ask participating insurers to search for policies and annuities.

Sources

What this page says about Scanner One was checked against the app on .

Last checked:

Get Scanner One

Scanner One is free, with generous limits: scanning, clean PDFs and text search never stop.